Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows
I have just finished watching the six episodes of the
BBC mini-series Sherlock
, and while it is an excellent
production, I have two big complaints about it. First of all
are the scope of the crimes, which tend to take on enormous
proportions. While the original also hints at Holmes' involvement
in delicate cases concerning royal houses,
there is no need to take it to an over-the-top level that would
better suit James Bond. The second, and more urgent, complaint are the cliffhanger season finales,
which seem to serve no purpose other than to drive the audience nuts
with speculation. I strongly advise anyone against watching The Reichenbach Fall
before the third season is available.
A good cliffhanger needs to be an important part of a story arch that
connects two seasons, and get resolved in a satisfactory fashion.
Otherwise we can all go back and watch Lost again.
Hollywood movies are also fertile ground for both these ingredients,
but fortunately A Game of Shadows
, while not avoiding them
altogether, uses them in a much more palatable way. Yes, there is a chase across
Europe, but that is in Conan Doyle's Moriarty story as well, yes, the plot
involves triggering a World War, but they make a point that Europe really was very explosive
at the time. These things are par for the course with big-budget franchise movies,
so one must be forgiving. And the ending is
just friendly hint that more sequels may be coming
instead of a nerve-wrecking cliffhanger.
Robert Downey, Jr. and Jude Law are still a perfect duo, the signature fight scenes from the first movie are back (where Holmes meticulously plans the action before it happens) and used very effectively in the final confrontation with Moriarty. Plus you can get a very good look indeed at Stephen Fry's brilliant Mycroft.
7 points






















